Andy Chan

2012年3月5日星期一

SMK jalan ARANG

停课,并不是一种很好的出发方式...

 We do understand why students are not allow to cheat during examinations. But, this particular teacher has been making a mountain out of a molehill. This teacher has been accusing students for things they did not do and this is certainly an unreasonable act. Normally, students are not allowed to fight against the teachers but to listen and obey. However, it is certainly unreasonable to punish students over something which they did not do. This is nothing more than just humiliations or worse, trauma for them. Therefore, affects their future developments in personalities and future achievements in academic.
Besides, we doubt the effectiveness of suspending students from school when they cheat during examinations. Punishing the students by suspending them from school is one of the way to make the students learn from mistakes but definitely not the best way. Some intelligent students will learn from this suspension and converse. Those who do not learn from the suspension will be grateful for the "extra holidays" given by school. Principal should give chances to students or to punish students in better ways other than suspending them from school. Positive ways to punish students would be much more preferred. Such as, clean the toilets or the school environment. It is a way to create awareness among students for not breaking the regulations and laws of school.
We hope that principal and teachers can be more rational, reasonable and fair to all students. Principal and teachers should try to find out the actual reasons instead of accusing them without further investigation. We do hope that principal could take reasonable actions towards this issue.

这是一些家长的心声,希望学校机构可以留意...
在此有一件不平的事情,希望校长与学校机构会了解...

学生在考试期间偷看,的确是一件不对的事情,校方也确实是应该处罚 那些学生。
不过,处罚学生的方法有很多种,并不是一定得要罚他们停课三天 来以示警告..
比起停课,校方更应该给予正面的 处罚或警告...
例如 心理补导,记过 或 从考, 都是一种好的处罚方式 来让他们知道,错在哪里进而让他们反省.
以停课来做处置并不是唯一以及最好的决定, 因为这将严重的影响到了学生幼小的心灵.

停课这种处置方法 未必会让学生从错误中学习,有些学生反倒认为多了三天假期,他们可以更为所欲为,甚至到处游荡.
这将可能引发更多的社会问题.
反观, 假若校方以更宽容的做法 例如 :捡垃圾,洗厕所 或 扫地.
我相信这些会比停课来得更有效率得多
一来 学生会觉得丢脸, 因为很多同学都在看他
二来 学校的环境也会因此得到改善.

在此,再次的希望校方以及学校机构的人们,正视这件事情...
我们不该以这种没有实际效用的处罚方式来对待学生..我也希望这种处罚 将被停止..
感谢您们聆听我的意见...


谢谢...